Dawn to Dusk vs Twilight to Starlight

[Jonny5]

oh, i just like everything willy touches

[i_adore_adore]

I feel like I need to clear something up.

What I was trying to say was that COMPARED TO MELLON COLLIE Siamese Dream is more boring. I wasn't trying to say SD sucks and I can't believe people actually like it (I save those comments for the TFE thread). I really do like Siamese Dream. I love more or less all of the songs, but for some reason as an album it doesn't feel... right. MCIS feels so complete every time I listen to it. Adore sounds complete, and Gish, and Machina (er, but I don't like Machina more than Siamese Dream, for the record). For some reason, SD just feels like a bunch of really great songs with a similar style put on a CD, and the rest of SP's albums feel like... well... albums.

[wilch]

Originally Posted by Liandrin

Regarding the Siamese Dream v. Mellon Collie comments:

I think SD is more consistent, while MCIS has the greater total number of good songs. There are some parts of MCIS that really feel out of place to me, like Love and Cupid de Locke on D2D (maybe that's intentional). Every song on SD sounds like it should be there.

If SD included the best of Pisces Iscariot, it would be no contest.

I like love i think it goes great on the album, and the neat little solo is off the heezy. IMO it would have made a great single in the late 90s.

[wilch]

SD is still my second or third fav album in the world though...