SAOSB Vol 3

[trev]

i don't get it, why is siamese dream vol 2 a pathetic move billy could never do, but saosb vol 1-4 is apparently still maintaining artistic integrity?

be consistent with your bullshit billy.

[FoolofaTook]

because he could never do siamese dreams 2. that's why he hates ppl talking about the golden era. he knows how far he's fallen and that he'll never regain even a smidgen of his former glory.

so he covers it up with bullshit excuses, media conspiracies, and INSTABLOCK!

[Cool As Ice Cream]

block of the nanosecond!

[CherryRay]

That's pretty much it

[FoolofaTook]

Your support is appreciated, CherryRay.

It would, however, be even more appreciated if you would back that shit up with a pos rep.

Kind Regards,

FoolofaTook

[CherryRay]

Well you were pretty succinct, didn't really need to add anything
But if you want, judging by that Sir Sly tune, he has the capacity to at least write or involve himself in good 'relevant' tunes and is awfully aware his voice and range isn't enough to engage current audiences, as much as he'd wish otherwise. Maybe that insecurity is holding him back on new Pumpkins material.

[Forgotten Child]

Maybe the insecurity is what he's lacking to up his game

[Forgotten Child]

[Ram27]

i like when he posts almost normal things

[and so many other songs too]

[enthusaroo]

I heard vol. 4 > vol. 3

[brothahi4L]

Yeah he is wäre that je eben cannot reproduce the Sound öffnen sd

[smashingjj]

Spot on!

[incubator]

Originally Posted by trev

i don't get it, why is siamese dream vol 2 a pathetic move billy could never do, but saosb vol 1-4 is apparently still maintaining artistic integrity?

be consistent with your bullshit billy.

You don’t see the difference between planning a series of albums and doing a follow up to an album that’s over 20 years old, written when he was basically a completely different person with a completely different mindset?

[incubator]

He’s a dick about some things but is on the knob about the fans stuck in the past thing. It’s like constantly telling your wife that she used to be pretty. If don’t love who she is now, move on. She’s never gonna be 24 again.

[thomas_bland]

Nah he could ignore those questions and not be a cock about it.

[FoolofaTook]

There was a fellah named Incubator
Who was quite an instigator
He liked to troll
The minions of B0ll
And all the hipsters and haters!

[incubator]

Originally Posted by thomas_bland

Nah he could ignore those questions and not be a cock about it.

He probably does ignore loads of questions like that.

This is a sad, strange world. I’m the undisputed voice of reason around here and am being accused of trolling. Trolling! SD2 would be as cynical as The Cures “trilogy”.

[incubator]

It’s like asking Sir Paul McCartney to do Sgt Peppers Lonely Hearts Club Band 2

[Joey Goldberg]

He already attempted SD2 and it was called Oceania

i don't remember the last i ever saw somebody genuinely request that

[Shadaloo]

For real. That album was full of fuzzy and varied guitar tones and I always felt that was an attempt at doing a new take on the SD atmosphere.

[incubator]

I think aside from it having fuzz and there being a couple of bits that I can only assume were deliberate references to SD songs,”fan service”, which WPC could heelingly act indignant about asking “how can I rip myself off??!”.. aside from those 2 things Oceania and SD are completely different.

[Joey Goldberg]

his whole mantra around that album was something along the lines of "see, I can still do this type of shit" so I think at least in his mind they were not so far apart

[incubator]

By “still do it” I think he meant get out of bed and write, record and release an album.

[MyKeyZ]

Oceania is nowhere near Siamese Dream. The moments where he tries to regurgitate Siamese Dream, it just comes off as Siamese Dream Lite. I'm sorry, but Billy cannot make a SD2.

[FoolofaTook]

OMG OMG



it's mykeyz!!!

[houseofglass11]

there's a few things on Oceania I like but there's some absolutely atrocious keyboard moments

[Ram27]

inkless is definitely a revamped hummer intro

[Forgotten Child]

[enthusaroo]

what are those hearts on bottom-right of the screen? it looks like some gay middle school shit

[Ram27]

he should stream the studio sessions