has rolling stone ever given a hip hop album five stars?

[Irrelevant]

ha. they also give the "remastered" Straight Outta Compton 5 stars, dated from October of this year.

[bonsor]

Originally posted by Tessellation
The fact is, ****** is an uppity, ugly pothead. The end.

Nice to see you keeping on track with the discussion.

[wounded]

Originally posted by Tessellation
RS is also the rag that gave two stars each to the RHCP's "BloodSugarSex..." and JA's "Ritual" and, most humorously, gave "nevermind" 3 stars.

yeah, the gave mellon collie 3 and TAFH 4, after MCIS blew up. i think it depends on who the reviewer is, but often it seems like they go with what is popular. they also change their minds, if nevermind was remastered it would get 5 stars.

Originally posted by wounded


yeah, the gave mellon collie 3 and TAFH 4, after MCIS blew up. i think it depends on who the reviewer is, but often it seems like they go with what is popular. they also change their minds, if nevermind was remastered it would get 5 stars.

No there are too many bad songs on it

[bloop]

Originally posted by Finsta


No there are too many bad songs on it

Has that ever stopped RS from giving out 5 stars to popular remasters before?

[Tessellation]

Originally posted by bloop


Has that ever stopped RS from giving out 5 stars to popular remasters before?

they've only started reviewing reissues and re-reviewing albums recently.

[bloop]

Originally posted by Tessellation


they've only started reviewing reissues and re-reviewing albums recently.

Good point, but they have already conformed to a pretty clear pattern in those reviews.