Rolling Stone's NEW 100 Greatest Guitarists list

[redbreegull]

Originally Posted by Trotskilicious

ah no, i didn't read any of that

if you would like me to break it down for you:

the person arguing the point has an audience of the other and vice versa. So if you're talking then ??? is the only one reading and if you're reading ???'s post to refute it, you're the only one doing so. See? Audience of one.

practicing rhetoric does not require, nor should it require, an audience outside the rhetoricians.

[redbull]

muse, anyone?

[Trotskilicious]

Originally Posted by redbreegull

practicing rhetoric does not require, nor should it require, an audience outside the rhetoricians.

[aztec litany service]

nice how they always mention moore and verlaine because they're 'frontmen'. lloyd and ranaldo are just as if not more awesome

belew not being on the list is a major error. dude is a fucking genius.

putting ppl like lennon/cobain/ramone/lou reed is silly. neil young did some interesting guitar stuff but it's obvious that he's known as a songwriter first and foremost. and save the bluesmen for the blues list.

robin guthrie and kevin shields deserve recognition for coming up w/ really original tones/atmospheres

steve howe [yes were the best prog band. listen to 'close to the edge' if you need any convincing. rush are overrated. good band of course, but anyway]

i'd prolly put bernard sumner on a list actually. sometimes subtlety is where it's at. the edge [or the evans as i call him cuz he stole my name] learned a lot from this guy.

my knowledge on guitarists isn't vast i admit, i'm way more interested in song craft than technical ability

anyway fuck rolling stone

[redbreegull]

I think that maybe none of you have actually listened to any neil young and are basing this on whichever two songs of his you have heard on the radio

[Trotskilicious]

i don't care about your dinosaurs!

carrie
brown
stein

[samuel redman]

joni mitchell should be number one

what kind of chords/progressions/broken notes she used we will never know

A LOT OF IT WASNT EVEN JAZZ

Originally Posted by aztec litany service

it's obvious that he's known as a songwriter first and foremost.

no this is not obvious you disgusting sloppy idiot
like forget what neil young these scumbags have heard, have you read anything about him? you little puke