Originally posted by TuralyonW3
Not a very good point. You could probably say that about most songs. I'm a big Bob Dylan fan, and his originals just don't sound near as good to me unless it's his voice and guitar playing. Billy wrote I'm Ready for his voice and guitar playing. If Mariah Carey did it, then yeah it would probably suck.
Case in Point: Listen to the I Am Sam Soundtrack
last night at the vic, live, there was a certain atmosphere created in this song, and i REALLY liked it. the music is amazing as well.
i think this comment is very accurate.