top tier: Tarantula only. Awesome song, perfect single. Good all the way through. Sick guitar.
2nd tier: Bring the Light and US. Half hit and half miss.
3rd tier: Doomsday, 7 Shades, Bleeding the Orchid, That's the Way, Neverlost. Ideas which could have gone in good directions but really fall flat because of bad execution failing to cover up lazy songwriting.
4th tier: Starz, For God, Pomp, Come on Let's Go. These would not be salvageable no matter what. Pomp sounds like a fucking Enya song.
again I think Oceania is a better collection of songs, but the lack of Jimmy makes it less of a Pumpkins album to me and probably to many listeners. Monuments and the other Teargarden songs are so bad in comparison to either Z or O though they basically don't even count in my mind.
|