Quote:
Originally Posted by teh b0lly!!1
rick rubin is a bullshit producer these days.
he certainly can (and has) legitimately wreck great songs with his awful production. the only reason he is still hired is because he's a brand name, a seal of approval for many people.
her'es a perfect case study for this.
same artist, same song, just different producer. first one is the original, second one produced by rubin for jake bugg's second/third album (i forget).
if you have the patience, listen to both the whole way through. the difference and lack of soul in rubin's production is staggeringly evident.
new version produced by rubin (song starts around the 1 minute mark):
allowfullscreen>
the funny thing is, i happened to listen to the rick rubin version first, before i knew anything about jake bugg. it just came on the radio or tv. i didn't care for it at all and moved on, forgetting about it. only years later i heard the original, loved it and realized i had heard the same song before. terrible fucking soulless producer.
|
Wow...incredible comparison.
The sound and mix of the drums is AWFUL in Rubin's version for example.
It's a much better build up with the rim click first in the original versiion by the way.
I also miss the vocal reverb from the original version.