Netphoria Message Board

Netphoria Message Board (http://forums.netphoria.org/index.php)
-   General Chat Archive (http://forums.netphoria.org/forumdisplay.php?f=19)
-   -   Suicide Prevention (http://forums.netphoria.org/showthread.php?t=3114)

gish1991 10-17-2002 02:07 AM

Suicide Prevention
 
Just wondering since this is a very talkative place and I have a feeling more than one of you hav egone through this . . . What would you guys/gals do if a friend of yours told you that they wanted to kill themselves?

I have absolutely no clue and I had a friend on the phone earlier who is going through some really bad stuff ranging from cancer, money issues, and now a totaled car with little chance of getting insurance for a new one. Not to mention some of the usual parent/child issues, but she called me today crying and saying she might not see me again and started to cut herself with me on the phone listening. I managed to keep her on the line for a while, and it seems like the cuts weren't bad enough to make it permanent, but I can see this happening again in the future. I just dunno if I can handle it again. So, what I am asking is if anyone has gone through this or knows anything about it, what did (would) you do in this situation?

I am desperate here, I don't want to lose a friend. Thanks for listening...

palidor 10-17-2002 02:14 AM

Wow. uhm, what age are we talking here?

That's a really difficult situation. I'm sorry you have to deal with that, I have no idea how I would handle it..

sickbadthing 10-17-2002 02:16 AM

I was totally distracted by the dancing banana.

gish1991 10-17-2002 02:24 AM

sorry, the banana just show you what kinda personality I really am and now I have to deal with something completely opposite and foreign to me . . . . .



and we are talking the mid-20's age range.

palidor 10-17-2002 02:28 AM

I really don't know what to do then. I guess I would try to find some sort of suicide hot-line #, because I'm sure they could point you in the right direction.

Regardless, suicide is NOT something to fuck around with. Imagine how you would feel if she killed herself and you didn't do anything. I would get on that right away if I were you.

Good luck.

sickbadthing 10-17-2002 02:30 AM

She needs professional help and if you can convince her of that then try that. If you know she is going to kill herself and she's serious, call the cops. It's not going to make her life any better but it may keep her from being dead.

cozmic 10-17-2002 03:30 AM

Call me heartless, but it pisses me off when people say things like that. Honestly, I haven't heard of many cases in which people who really committed suicide told people they were going to do it beforehand. I mean, in order to tell someone you are going to kill yourself, you have to really want them to feel sorry for you. Why else would you tell them? I think it's selfish and pathetic. It's difficult for me to pity people like that. People that tell you things like that are looking for a power trip. They want to force you to a point of desperation.

In my opinion, suicide is a cheap escape from life's tribulations. It's like cutting in line.

I went through this with a friend in high school. On several occasions, we would be talking through AIM and he would say things like "I just want to end it all." To which I would reply with the obligatory, "Chad, don't talk like that. I really care about you... blah blah blah blah." It was useless. Because he would just say things like "Never mind. What do you care?" It went on and on and on. I always wonder how he would have responded if I had told him to go ahead and do it. But then if he really had killed himself, wouldn't I feel like shit?

I'm not saying your friend doesn't have issues. Obviously she does. But it is wrong of her to make those problems become yours. Why tell a friend you're thinking about suicide? I still don't get it. It almost seems egotistic.

Since she has put you in this awkward position... you obviously feel the need to do something to prevent her possible death. I'm sure she knows this too. So instead of alerting someone she is close to, like a parent (since there are obviously issues there), I would visit http://www.hopeline.com or call 1-800-SUICIDE and ask how you can directly get her professional help. She needs to learn how to cope. Then if she's not willing to accept help... that's not your problem. I have found that spoken reassurance is absolutely useless. There's really nothing more you can do... other than hire someone to watch her 24/7. (That could become quite expensive.)

Apart 10-17-2002 08:00 AM

haha. cozmic has to be the dumbest piece of shit on the boards! REAL smart babble right there!

yeah, suicide hotlines REALLY work. a friend of mine called a few of them a couple years back, and get this..they actually hung up on him because "he didnt know what he wanted". lmfao!! yea, they REALLY give a shit! so go ahead, call them. they know oh so much about your friends and their problems!

Crono 10-17-2002 10:37 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by cozmic
of course they're looking for attention. The person is incredibly depressed. Any kind of positive attitudes toward their life, no matter how they respond, helps them. If you feed them negative feelings then they feel justified and feed upon their pain. They're looking for justification for how they're feeling or an argument for why everything sucks and will be better.

KrazeeStacee 10-17-2002 11:28 AM

Show them as much love and positive attitude as you can, try to get them to get help. If all else fails, like whoever said...call the cops. At least they won't be dead that way.

My mom told my alcoholic dad she wanted a divorce several years ago, he got drunk and slit his whole arm open. When the ambulance finally came, he was in the bathroom with the door locked screaming about how he wanted to die, they busted the door down and when he resisted being taken, the one girl punched him and knocked him out, then they dragged him into the ambulance...haha, sorry...so basically, you gotta do whatever it takes.

Apart 10-17-2002 03:35 PM

haha. right on phorians. cozmic is obviously a severely fucked over cunt who doesnt understand jack shit about anything!

then again, who didnt know this from the start? lmao. what an ugly ignorant cunt. hehe...

Undone 10-17-2002 03:38 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by killtheyouth


you're obviously completely ignorant of the suicidal mind. not only that, but it's retarded to suggest that suicidal people not tell anyone. do you have any idea how many suicidal people HAVE told someone and gotten help? the actual percentage of suicidal people that make a real attempt isnt that high, and the success rate of attempts isnt that high. so maybe they should just ALL shut up and off themselves? i bet some of your friends have gotten help by telling someone and you dont even know it.

go take a psych course.

^ What he said.

But back to the original poster. You can tell your friend that you'll listen to her and always be her friend, but she has to make a conscious effort to stop being manipulative as that is unfair and unhelpful to both of you. I don't know how suicide hotlines work, though I wouldn't trust them too much-- It would be nice if you could find someone on there that is a decent person and knows what to do instead of it being a totally random person who is pretending to listen but blowing her boyfriend at the same time as being on the phone.

Undone 10-17-2002 03:40 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Apart
haha. right on phorians. cozmic is obviously a severely fucked over cunt who doesnt understand jack shit about anything!

then again, who didnt know this from the start? lmao. what an ugly ignorant cunt. hehe...

Everyone makes assumptions every day about things they don't understand, oftentimes false ones. It doesn't mean she's a stupid cunt--unless she refuses to learn of course. ;)

Apart 10-17-2002 03:43 PM

undone, ladies and gentlemen. coming to the defense of fucking morons, and she loves to do...being a fucking moron herself..of course. lets have a round of applause for the ignorant ugly cunt!
and watch and she dazzles us with more vital information!

mirrar 10-17-2002 03:50 PM

I work at a suicide prevention hotline, and I can say that we've got the odd horrible worker there who wouldn't help her at all, but the screening process is pretty intensive and so is the training so the majority tend to be pretty good. If you were to call one for her, the main thing they'd try and do for you would be to provide "care to the caregiver" and help you try and get some of your feelings off your chest so they're not as much of a burden on you. Hotlines don't usually give direct advice to a third party caller, because it's hard to asess the situation accurately from an outside point of view. If you could get her to call one herself it would probably be beneficial, but she has to be willing to talk about her problems honestly or there's really no point in calling, unless an intervention is needed and in that case it takes time for the helpline worker to call 911 so it's better to just do that yourself if possible. But yeah I think you should call one, they can also give you referrals to councilling agencies/community health groups in your area that you can try and convince her to attend. And yeah like the other people said, that was a really ignorant thing to say, Cozmic, you should really do some research before shooting your mouth off like that. Suicide/suicidal thoughts is are incredibly complex things that vary so much from person to person, you can't make generalizations about any of the factors because it's so different in every case.

Apart 10-17-2002 03:56 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Mirror_Untrue
we NEVER hang up on people who are thinking about suicide! call us...we promise!!! ignore the facts and what you've heard, we care! we really do!
moron :rolleyes:

mirrar 10-17-2002 03:59 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Apart


moron :rolleyes:

Actually, we do. If you're not willing to talk, we try and make people communicate as much as possible, but if they're being surly and nasty and the volunteer feels they can't be of help to them, we end the call.

Apart 10-17-2002 04:07 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Mirror_Untrue

your point has been proven.


thank you.

mirrar 10-17-2002 04:11 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Apart



thank you.

refresh my memory on how i proved that hotlines are bullshit please. Oh, unless you think there's benefit to sitting on the phone for long periods of time with someone who is verbally abusive (much like yourself) or who refuses to talk, tying up the phonelines for other callers trying to get through.

Apart 10-17-2002 04:12 PM

whats that? more idiocy babble? more ego talk? good for you. you know it all, fool!

mirrar 10-17-2002 04:14 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Apart
whats that? more idiocy babble? more ego talk? good for you. you know it all, fool!
i'm sorry a hotline hasn't been able to help you with your problems. Maybe we all just need more training just to deal with your special and incredibly facinating case.

Apart 10-17-2002 04:20 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Mirror_Untrue

yet MORE ego babble.

haha, stupid cunt. too bad you were far too stupid to read anything that was typed above your posts. ugly ignorant dumbfuck. hahaha

mirrar 10-17-2002 04:24 PM

Too bad i actually WORK at a hotline and decided to give some insight into the kinds of things we do.. God you facinate me.

Apart 10-17-2002 04:25 PM

you're stupidity facinates me! but not surprising, after all..you belong here on netphoria with these morons. keep up the good work, ugly cunt!

mirrar 10-17-2002 04:31 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Apart
you're stupidity facinates me! but not surprising, after all..you belong here on netphoria with these morons. keep up the good work, ugly cunt!
you know what? you've never attacked me before. I feel as if i've been blessed by the great spirit of nevermind. My life is complete. *Happy sigh*

Boner 10-17-2002 04:42 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Apart

haha, stupid cunt. too bad you were far too stupid to read anything that was typed above your posts. ugly ignorant dumbfuck. hahaha

I get the sense that Apart is the only person on here with more pent-up anger than me.

Are you really as pissed off as you seem or is it all just schtick.

Oh yeah on the topic, I don't think there's any statistical accuracy to the statement that someone who talks abou killing themself will not do it.

You have to look more at the person.

My mom threatened to commit suicide after losing going blind in her left eye two years ago. She eventually had a nervous breakdown and spent six months in the care of others. All the while saying she was gonna kill herself.

No one took it that seriously (we were scared don't get me wrong) but not because she talked about it. It was more that she is kind of a weak-willed person. Not one to take initiative. The doctors said the only way someone with her personality would committ suicide was overdosing on pills because other methods (gun, slit wrist, etc.) requires more physical drive than she had.

And she never oded on pills so life is better these days. Kind of.

Apart 10-17-2002 04:55 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Mirror_Untrue

you know what? you've never attacked me before. I feel as if i've been blessed by the great spirit of nevermind. My life is complete. *Happy sigh*


until now you showed only mild stupidity, and were simply known as just another ugly bitch here.

but now that you've proven yourself royally stupid and ignorant, you are worthy of one thread of sad..yet truthful insults from me. congratulations. :)

spa ced 10-17-2002 04:57 PM

So those suicidine hotlines must really work though
Since Apart is still here...

James is Cool 10-17-2002 04:59 PM

By talking to you the way she did and threatening suicide, she's crying for help. I doubt she's actually going to carry through with killing herself, but you don't want to deal with the chance of that happening. Do what you can to make her feel better and get help immediately.

I went through this with a friend a few weeks ago.

Apart 10-17-2002 05:08 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by The Ace of Aces


I get the sense that Apart is the only person on here with more pent-up anger than me.

Are you really as pissed off as you seem or is it all just schtick.

well, you ought to think what every other depressed dumbfuck here does about me. hope that i really do have that pent up anger so you can feel better about yourself in comparison. it's much easier to think of me that way, isint it? heh. go ahead and join the club.

Apart 10-17-2002 05:09 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by sp_aced
So those suicidine hotlines must really work though
Since Apart is still here...

ohhh an ugly blamo cunt. how adorable. still getting fucked over? lol

mirrar 10-17-2002 05:13 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Apart



until now you showed only mild stupidity, and were simply known as just another ugly bitch here.

but now that you've proven yourself royally stupid and ignorant, you are worthy of one thread of sad..yet truthful insults from me. congratulations. :)

*high five*

BlueStar 10-17-2002 05:16 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Graveflower
I figure it's as selfish to want to "keep" someone who is obviously in a lot of pain as it is for that person to kill themselves. Yeah, it's a real easy way out, too. What a load of crap. People don't just go "gee I think I'll shoot myself in the head" and do it, it's not an easy decision.
Exactly.

Generally the most common thing heard regarding someone who has committed suicide is "I had no clue, never saw it coming." By telling you she is thinking about committing suicide, she is reaching out to you and seeking help. The best thing is probably to try and convince her to see a psychiatrist.

Has she ever been depressed before? Is she a "cutter" or was that time on the phone the first time she has done that? (If she is a "cutter", cutting oneself usually has nothing to do with suicide/there is no intent for it to lead to suicide.)

Threats of suicide don't come out of nowhere...something has been going on with her and it has been going on for awhile.

spa ced 10-17-2002 05:20 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Apart


ohhh an ugly blamo cunt. how adorable. still getting fucked over? lol

I don't go to Siva you dumbfuck.

Apart 10-17-2002 05:26 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by sp_aced


I'm a dumbfuck.


spa ced 10-17-2002 05:30 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Apart
I feel sorry for you.
I really do.

Apart 10-17-2002 06:27 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by sp_aced


I feel sorry for you.
I really do.

wow, you must care then! fuckin loser. heh.

whatever helps your ego!

cozmic 10-17-2002 09:39 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by killtheyouth


you're obviously completely ignorant of the suicidal mind. not only that, but it's retarded to suggest that suicidal people not tell anyone. do you have any idea how many suicidal people HAVE told someone and gotten help? the actual percentage of suicidal people that make a real attempt isnt that high, and the success rate of attempts isnt that high. so maybe they should just ALL shut up and off themselves? i bet some of your friends have gotten help by telling someone and you dont even know it.

go take a psych course.

I don't believe I am ignorant of the suicidal mind. I spent many of my adolescent years becoming personally acquainted with it. I form my opinions from experience. And I did not suggest that someone who is suicidal should not talk with anyone. I was referring to the manner in which his friend has burdened him with her possible suicide. She should be directed to confide in a professional counselor/psychiatrist... someone who is trained to deal with an issue that sensitive in nature. If you were to counsel a suicidal friend alone without involving a professional and she killed herself, you would have to feel rather nescient.

And I suppose I tend to ground my feelings from an existentialist's point of view... I feel that we are responsibile for the consequences of our own actions. If someone wishes to end their life that badly... that is their wish. It seems rather selfish that, in most cases, our only reason for interjection is to prevent our own loss and sadness.

Also, I don't believe someone is ignorant simply because they have feelings that conflict with the views of others... yet that tends to be a belief that has always been rampantly common on netphoria...

(By the way, I have taken several psychology courses while in college. I performed quite well in them.) :)

gish1991 10-18-2002 01:38 AM

Thank You
 
Thank You so much all who responded to the original subject. Your posts are geratly appreciated and exactly what I was hopin for, especially from people that actually work(ed) in a situation like that.

A little update : things are slightly better. The wrist wounds weren't that bad and are healing and she has some family support, mostly her little sister. But the bad news is that her pet died earlier today :( throw some more needles on that camel's back already!!! Jeez! Her only in-house companion is now gone so it won't be easier, but at least she is somewhat stable at the moment and I think I am making a difference, but I think I will still call one of those hotlines for any additional advice.


Again, I thank those of you who offered up some great advice, I really needed it.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 09:49 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2020, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.

Smashing Pumpkins, Alternative Music
& General Discussion Message Board and Forums
www.netphoria.org - Copyright © 1998-2020