Netphoria Message Board

Netphoria Message Board (http://forums.netphoria.org/index.php)
-   General Chat Archive (http://forums.netphoria.org/forumdisplay.php?f=19)
-   -   Kindle, nook, or ipad or macbook? (http://forums.netphoria.org/showthread.php?t=170816)

obscured01 07-03-2010 02:05 AM

Kindle, nook, or ipad or macbook?
 
Which would you choose? My birthday's coming up and I was given these options. I already have an iphone and an ibook (it's a g4, but it's still trucking), so I'm not so sure about the macbook, (the camera would be nice, and the ability to play games since there are very few games available for the pwerpc still) or an ipad, since I already have two devices which essentially do what it does. I know the ipad has an ereader and kindle app, but I've read since it's not a dedicated ereader, it's hard on the eyes for long periods of time. Between the kindle and nook, I'm leaning towards the nook because of a larger selection and the lending option, but I've read the os is slower than the kindle for downloading etc.

I've never had an ereader, but I do a lot of reading and spend a pretty stupid amount on books, so it would be great but I'm just not sure which is really better. The ipad is awesome, but I just don't really see getting an ipad which could be subpar for reading, with all these extra things that I can already do on my ibook or iphone. But then I'm concerned that the ipad will take over the ereader business, and then either the kindle or nook will become totally outdated and the amount of books will be limited.

Whatta ya think?

obscured01 07-03-2010 02:08 AM

The title to this really sucks. It should've said kindle, nook, ipad or macbook.

strange_one 07-03-2010 02:11 AM

Kindle is probably the best choice at the moment. The ipad screen is too bright for reading unless it's in short bursts; it's better for reading comic books.

The Kindle dropped to US$189 last month too so it's a good time to nab one

Mo 07-03-2010 02:21 AM

Macbook, hands down.

memories_unwind 07-03-2010 07:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mo (Post 3632149)
Macbook, hands down.

.

Luke de Spa 07-03-2010 08:15 AM

you should overclock your ibook and get it liquid-cooled

way faster than intel's shitty silicon

Nothing/everything 07-03-2010 09:24 AM

Macbook. Buy the books second-hand for a couple of $$$ and be the proud owner of a full bookshelf in your livingroom.

JokeyLoki 07-03-2010 12:50 PM

I absolutely love my nook. Can't say a negative thing about it.

obscured01 07-03-2010 01:29 PM

The thing is, I don't really use my ibook for much more than I would use an ipad for. I really just use it for the internet, mail, videos and flash games. I'm not in school anymore so I don't need the wordprocessing, but I've got access to two other computers if I need word processing.

But I already have an iphone so do I need an ipad?

I should have added the options I was given was ipad + nook or kindle or a macbook.

murgle 07-03-2010 01:37 PM

I've only ever used a kindle, and it's great.

Loads very quickly, INCREDIBLY easy on the eyes, and the price just dropped massively.

At her Christmas party, my friend showed me hers that she got for Christmas, and I then spent 2 hours reading a book on it. (Coraline, btw. Very good book) I finished the book just as quickly as I would've done otherwise, and my eyes were not strained at ALL. Amazing.

I hear the Nooks are nice, too. Their price dropped as well. I just haven't used one.

Trotskilicious 07-03-2010 03:12 PM

yeah who needs a book when you can pay 199 bucks for something that does the same thing!!!

Trotskilicious 07-03-2010 03:13 PM

BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT!

pale_princess 07-03-2010 07:26 PM

Wow, the tough decisions some people have to make in their lives :rolleyes:

Mooney 07-03-2010 08:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nothing/everything (Post 3632199)
Buy the books second-hand for a couple of $$$ and be the proud owner of a full bookshelf in your livingroom.

seriously. i'm pretty sure that 85% of the reason for reading is to show off to your redneck friends just how anti-anti-intellectualism you are. i don't even read four quarters of the books i buy.

Order 66 07-03-2010 08:46 PM

I think the future of ebooks is in smartphones. but if I had to get one now I'd get a kindle

Future Boy 07-03-2010 09:02 PM

ipad, then gift it to me. You dont want to read, readings for suckers.

Fonzie 07-04-2010 01:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Trotskilicious (Post 3632235)
BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT! BUY MORE SHIT!

that's exactly what I thought.

Starla 07-04-2010 06:45 AM

I don't see the appeal of using a kindle. I sat next to someone on a flight who was using one... I guess I'm old school and would rather hold a book in my hands.

Mablak 07-04-2010 07:29 AM

I can infer that a macbook is a laptop, but I seriously don't know what any of this crap is. Why the fuck can't people name things according to what they do? I don't want to hear about hand held devices called nookies or shprockets, just put the word 'phone' in there somehow. And if it's more than a phone, call it a mobile shitfucking multifucker apparatus or something for fuck's sake.

Luke de Spa 07-04-2010 09:25 AM

iPad and Kindle Reading Speeds (Jakob Nielsen's Alertbox)

applepwnz 07-04-2010 03:41 PM

If you're happy with your iBook still, I'd go with iPad + Nook

exactlythesame 07-04-2010 04:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mablak (Post 3632305)
call it a mobile shitfucking multifucker apparatus or something for fuck's sake.

The new iFucker. From Apple.

Fonzie 07-04-2010 05:05 PM

she'd WANT WANT WANT WANT one of them too.

Fonzie 07-04-2010 05:05 PM

this is a 'My Super Sweet 16' parody thread, right?

pale_princess 07-04-2010 05:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fonzie (Post 3632350)
this is a 'My Super Sweet 16' parody thread, right?

:banging:

Future Boy 07-04-2010 06:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mablak (Post 3632305)

.

pale_princess 07-04-2010 07:02 PM

http://stereogum.com/img/sia-some_pe...lems-cover.jpg

obscured01 07-04-2010 08:19 PM

You guys suck. I don't see what this has to do with me want want wanting anything. I didn't say "hey I'm really selfish get me all this shit for my birthday".
Obviously I'm not on the up and up about these things or I wouldn't be running a 6 year old ibook.
I was expecting Trueblood on dvd and that was about it, but was told I could have any of these, pick which one I would prefer - and all of them are pretty expensive purchases and some of them (the e-readers in particular) I know virtually nothing about) so I was looking for some one who might have these devices to let me know what they think about them, and compared to the others which one is best.

It's not a serious problem, but I don't want to be bitch and have him spend all this money on something that neither of us will get a lot of use out of etc. Just trying to make an informed decision.

And Shaunna, quit talking so much shit - it's a program he's working on with your country's DND that'll be paying for this. Go Canada.

applepwnz 07-04-2010 08:37 PM

I have a MacBook Pro (about 3-4 years old) and I love it, it's nice to be able to tri-boot Mac OS X + Windows 7 + Ubuntu. My mother has an iPad and absolutely loves it. As for kindle and nook, I don't think i actually know anyone who has either, but my mom has no complaints about the ebook reader on the iPad, someone said it was too bright, but it has a brightness control right in the reader so you can easily turn the brightness down if necessary.

Order 66 07-04-2010 08:42 PM

Why are you so selfish obscured. Its always just WANT WANT WANT and you never take anybody else into consideration


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 12:37 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2020, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.

Smashing Pumpkins, Alternative Music
& General Discussion Message Board and Forums
www.netphoria.org - Copyright © 1998-2020