Most overrated bands according to posters of Netphoria (so far):

U2
Rolling Stones
Pearl Jam
Radiohead/Animal Collective/Neutral Milk Hotel/Red Hot Chili Peppers
Metallica/Pink Floyd/Tool
The Doors/The Who/At the Drive-In/The Beatles
Modest Mouse/Decemberists/Pixies/JoyDivision/Wilco/My Bloody Valentine/Bob Dylan/The White Stripes/R.E.M./Pavement

What I tried to say was that being liked by a certain subculture has no effect on my opinion on music. At least I hope so, I did find Muse fans to be dicks in general once upon a time and it did sour my feelings towards the band back then.

I'm done arguing. English is not my first language, I don't always come across as well as I'd like to.

i never said the bands i named were overrated

this would be representational of any internet message board

Aside from a few really good songs, I just can't get into Neil Young. I am currently trying but nothing is sticking. :(

i guess this means you don't like guitars. or music. or sound in general.

yup that's exactly it rockin cherub

im just being silly but neil young is so amazing

i'm trying, though. i've gone through s/t through harvest

so far i like albuquerque, emperor of wyoming, Here We Are in the Years, needle and the damage done, i've been waiting for you, down By the river, and old man

and i guess heart of gold/cinnamon girl but i've heard them so much, it's kinda hard to tell if i like them or just accept them

get on the beach and live at massey hall

Or maybe they just find it tiresome to listen to overcompressed clipping macbook-internal-soundcard recorded garage minimalist trash with occasional "ironic" 808, DX7 and handclaps thrown in for a good measure just because 1988-born pitchfork writers say it's more ironic to do than to listen to all those overproduced 90's dinosarus?

Cortez the Killer?

Trans too I would think

yeah, good call redman:think:

i don't know who you are but im not so sure that was a good call

On The Beach is so so so much better then I remember. This has been a great day.

After the Goldrush is wonderful.

guys i think the problem is that neil young's voice pretty much gets on my nerves.:(

Neil Young is the voice of my last 5 years

guys does it help me at all that i really like what i've been hearing from new order?

not really no

harvard
mit

:(

new order > neil young

britney spears > neil young

ronnie james dio > neil young

DIOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

<3

^^^^^

yeah you know what my first actual contribution to this thread will be Pink Floyd.

shocking but FUCK YOU PLAY ZEPPELIN

i really, really like elvis costello

can i be cool now, guys?:blush:

Neil Young Update!

SO FAR I like the following albums: Life (87) & Harvest Moon (92)

one of my fave songs now is "Dreamin' Man". what a beautiful fucking song.

also i like the following songs to varying degrees:
albuquerque, borrowed tune, capt kennedy, come on baby let's go downtown, emperor of wyoming, hangin' on a limb, heart o gold, here we are in years, hey hey my my, if i could have her tonight, ive been waiting for you, my my hey hey, needle and the damage done, old man, pocahontas, powderfinger, rockin' in the free world, sedan delivery, someday, thrasher, too far gone (both versions), and wrecking ball

this thread makes me want to listen to My Bloody Valentine.

MBV MBV MBV MBV MBV MBV MBV MBV MBV MBV MBV MBV MBV MBV MBV MBV MBV

I found Isn't Anything amongst random cheap-o CDs at a Cargo Largo for $3 and, even though I had it on my hard drive, I bought the CD because I couldn't bear letting it just sit there unappreciated.:smoke:

MBV MBV MBV MBV MBV MBV MBV MBV MBV MBV MBV MBV MBV MBV MBV MBV MBV

Nirvana. Totally serious.

i can't imagine ever wanting/needing to hear any nirvana song ever again. probably aged the worst out of what i used to like.

even if somewhere someone discovers like 100 tapes of all new, never ever heard cobain solo demos, i'd fucking pass. his voice is the bane of my existence.

i don't think not being into nirvana is particularly unusual

When nevermind came out i was listening to the weird al version. I'm a late bloomer :(