| sawdust restaurants |
04-24-2002 06:09 PM |
Quote:
Originally posted by Silverstream:
i never said you were a clueless fucking male. But the fact remains that you DONT know what menstuation is like. until you do, i suggest that you keep your opinions to yourself because no matter how "informed" you are, you still arent a female and thus you will never understand.
|
This is the worst argument for anything, ever. "You don't know how it feels" doesn't mean you can't have an opinion steeped in a scientific basis, and there's lots of scientific basis for many arguments on menstruation. When you begin to discuss serious emotional traumas such as abortion, the argument gains more validity; but, shit, what we're talking about is menstruation, which, while horribly bothersome for women, is also steeped in biology and physiology, and, therefore, science, as opposed to the infinitely gray spectrum of ethics with things like abortion.
I'm not saying you're right or wrong--although for the record, my girlfriend has been on the pill for a long time solely to regulate her period, it has done her wonders, and I'd probably agree with you on the matter if pressed--but I am saying that you can't negate science simply because a man doesn't have a period. By your logic, woman psychologists can't study aggressive tendencies inherent in males, male anthropologists can't make conclusions on the validity of female gender roles in ancient society, and taken to its logical extreme, men in bands and women in bands can't have opinions on each other.
[This message has been edited by sawdust restaurants (edited 04-24-2002).]
|