Poll: Favorite member of SP? (Classic era)
 

I think my avatar makes my choice obvious. Billy would probably be my favorite musician ever if he was even somewhat of a likable person, but here we are.

who are these people?

Josh Radnor

Hmmm it’s actually really hard to pick

All of them are (or at least were) likeable for differnt reasons. Jim for the drums. Big willie for the feelins. D’arcy for the enigmatic cool. Iha for the easygoing slacker gaze

When it comes down to it i suppose iha has no qualities that i don’t like, and has seemed to retain his dignity and remained classy throughout the post-2000 period in a way the others haven’t as much...

So gosh i guess iha? Wow im learning about myself tonite

Josh Dude

but honestly though, Machina

jimmy > darcy > billy / james

can't split the last two. james feels so replaceable, but billy is such a dick.

That dude on the left looks pretty chill for a guy in a band with three chicks

The Asian chick.

Racist. It's a Japanese American chick.

No ones voting for the lanky babe?

that's fucking hilarious

someone send these results to his next Q&A

Doesn’t he block people a lot on his IG

damn this got me kinda tempted to do a b0llzcorgz vs Jack Bates ultimate pole.

probs throw in mark macgrath for shits n giggles

You think you’re better than Jack Bates?

you think you're better than anyone?

Fool, I AM Jack Bates!!!

FoolofaBates

I prefer TookBates, pls and thank u.

Hey Jack, any chance Billy will ever do the cybermetal again?

This poll is faulty, and frankly I'm a little disappointed

None of you have remembered the most important member of the band, the one without whose grace they could never have made such beautiful music

I mean of course our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ the Redeemer

Anyway I voted for Jimmy

God is empty.

Not if he's Iommi.

That was a difficult, testing time in Billy's young life where he was questioning everything

Here is what Jesus told him

Here's another important moment in SP history



Those are Jesus' numchuks on the doorknob

this is essentially jesus and an aging hesher’s creative reenactment of the scene on the night of the chamberlin / melvoin incident, 7:30 pm

Hey I never noticed that hand print on the door. Is the Holy Ghost?