If you treated Pisces Iscariot as one of the albums, where would you rank it?
 

I'd say it'd have to go after SD & MCIS. As an album it's their 3rd best, above Adore.

after machina.

there is some good stuff on there but it doesn't flow like an album. its choppy. like judas o

I think it flows pretty well, especially the end of it. The end of that album flows better than any other SP album.

it be just above Z right below SD

Adore, MCIS, SD, PI, Z, Gish, Machina & Machina II tie

although Z PI and Gish could get mixed around for me.. depends on my mood

check out monte with the gangster talk.

#3

del

4th

SD,MCIS,Adore,PI

^
Agreed. I like Pisces Iscariot as an album. It's pretty solid.

Agreed; but MCIS is first.

PI flows very well.

Adore, MCIS, SD, PI, Machina II, Gish, Machina, Zeitgeist

SD, MCIS, Aeroplane Box Set, PI, Gish, Adore, Zeitgeist, Machina 2, Machina 1.

ah fuck now we're throwing tafh in on this? god damnit

adore mcis tafh sd pi M2 gish MI zeit

actually i would almost say tafh is better than mcis

Some of my favorite songs are on Pisces.

Obscured, Starla, La Dolly Vita


I consider it sort of a Siamese Dream 2 and rank it among their best.

MCIS
TAFH
Adore
SD
Machina 2
Machina 1
Zeitgeist
PI
Gish

MCIS
Machina I
Machina II
TAFH
Zeitgeist / Adore / SD...can't really separate these three...I can see the genius of SD but never listen to it...I can see the flaws of Zeitgeist but can't stop listening to it...
PI
Gish

mellon collie
machina2
siamese
adore
pisces
.
.
.

Siamese Dream
Mellon Collie
Adore
Gish
TAFH
Pisces
Machina II
Machina
American Gothic
Zeitgeist

Adore > MCIS > SD > TAFH > PI > Machina > Z > Machina II > AG

And Adore, MCIS and SD can all change around depending on my mood.

i don't understand how so many people think M2 is better than M1. Totally nonsensical.

ill get bojangled for this but : MCIS, adore, machina, siamese dream, pisces, zeitgeist

they are all almost equally sweet anyway so no point ranking them

and i have a large penis

SD
MCIS
PISCES
GISH
ADORE
MACHINA
ZEITGEIST

for the time being..

i'd put it below sd, adore, and mcis. so it would be #4 for me. i love it.

I did for a long time. Now I prefer Machina I. The first 4 songs on Machina II is probably my favourite opening of a Pumpkins album unless you cound MCIS and ignore the first instrumental track.

Machina II could have been better than the first if a few songs were switched with B-sides...Vanity for Go, Speed Kills for La Deux Machina.

Here's to the Atom Bomb is awesome for some reason.

if people are doing all out rankings

MCIS
SD
PI
Adore
TAFH
Gish
Zeitgeist
Machina
Machina 2

PI is definitely one of my favorites.

Gish
Pisces
MCIS
TAFH
Adore
Siamese
Machina II
Machina I
Zeitgeist

Holy shit, I'm two posts out from 3K. I'd better make it count.

Agree with above poster: PI is the #4 SP album. btw, HKK is better than anything off Machina I or II. so that solves that problem.

#1 or #2 after SD, just depends I guess

Adore
Mellon Collie
Gish
P.I.
Siamese Dream
Machina II
Machina

I havent heard all of Zeitgeist, only two songs. So I'm not going to rank that one.