Which of the blue skies bring tears versions is your fav. Discuss.
While talking about blue skies bring tears, i've heard 4 vesions, the machina, the machina II, the acoustic and then another one which i cant quite indentify, its played like the machina version but with clean guitars, bass and vox. Anyone know what this is, a demo?

Originally posted by chrismca
Which of the blue skies bring tears versions is your fav. Discuss.
While talking about blue skies bring tears, i've heard 4 vesions, the machina, the machina II, the acoustic and then another one which i cant quite indentify, its played like the machina version but with clean guitars, bass and vox. Anyone know what this is, a demo?

live show version maybe?

Originally posted by fenderblender


live show version maybe?

no definately not

il get me jacket...

The Arising! Version is the other version. It is also my favorite.
There are more than 4 versions of that song.
The Machina and Machina II versions, The Arising!, The acoustin solo demos, the live 2000 version and the acoustic full band storytellers version come to mind. I am pretty sure that is all the variations on that song, but there could be more.

Originally posted by GrungeGuy
The Arising! Version is the other version. It is also my favorite.
There are more than 4 versions of that song.
The Machina and Machina II versions, The Arising!, The acoustin solo demos, the live 2000 version and the acoustic full band storytellers version come to mind. I am pretty sure that is all the variations on that song, but there could be more.
yea, i was just gonna say that....*ahem*

Originally posted by chrismca
While talking about blue skies bring tears, i've heard 4 vesions, the machina, the machina II, the acoustic and then another one which i cant quite indentify, its played like the machina version but with clean guitars, bass and vox. Anyone know what this is, a demo?
probably the demo from the FAEOMM tape (ends with "aahhh, aaaahhh aahhhh...").

also, there are two different acoustic demos, plus several different live versions:
the Arising! tour (most similar to the FAEOMM tape, but faster and with big jam at the end),
Resume The Pose tour (basically identical to MACHINA album),
Cat's Cradle (one-time only, just Billy on piano),
early Sacred + Profane tour (like RTP, but the end speeds up, with just Billy singing and Jimmy's drums, then goes into something like the MACHINA 2 version),
late Sacred + Profane tour (starts like RTP, speeds up halfway through to something like the Arising! version),
Storytellers/euro S+P tour (acoustic guitars, piano and keyboard, ends with Jimmy's drum solo [except Storytellers, of course]).

probably the demo from the FAEOMM tape (ends with "aahhh, aaaahhh aahhhh...").

Commonly known as Arising! Tour version.

MUCH better than that overproduced monstrosity on Machina.

Originally posted by Fonzie
probably the demo from the FAEOMM tape (ends with "aahhh, aaaahhh aahhhh...").

Commonly known as Arising! Tour version.

MUCH better than that overproduced monstrosity on Machina.
it's commonly called that, but it's significantly different from the version they played on the Arising! tour.
i much prefer the monstrosity, myself.

Originally posted by tcm


i much prefer the monstrosity, myself.

U R GAY.:p

I wish the Machina version exploded into the MII version. Imagine.

Originally posted by tcm

early Sacred + Profane tour (like RTP, but the end speeds up, with just Billy singing and Jimmy's drums, then goes into something like the MACHINA 2 version),

Originally posted by MMBKG
I wish the Machina version exploded into the MII version. Imagine.
Cool Edit.

automatic

version electrique :cool:

machina one version

M2 version is my favorite.

All the versions are bad. It is a bad song.

Originally posted by Dead

Cool Edit.


somebody with mad skillz should get their ass on this.

i'd be interested to hear it...

Originally posted by Fonzie
probably the demo from the FAEOMM tape (ends with "aahhh, aaaahhh aahhhh...").

Best = Machina
Worst = Machina 2

Originally posted by dean moriaty
somebody with mad skillz should get their ass on this.

i'd be interested to hear it...
I could do it but it wouldn't be a smooth transition. Maybe someone else can do a good one.

FAEOMM tape version is my favorite studio version, but I love the US Machina tour live versions with the crazy guitar solo at the end.

Originally posted by Dead

Cool Edit.

I tried to do it a while ago...it's sorta cool, but I can't quite get it to export correctly. And the transition is sort of disruptive. It happens right after "traces of your self-esteem" and uses the static afterwards to explode. It's alright.

Acid Pro 4.0

Machina 2 - easy no brainer. How anyone could like the sludge of the M1 version over the rockiness of the M2 version is beyond me.

Machina and Arising! tour versions.

thanks all, except for the person that said they all suck;) its damn cool