...the Pumpkins got back together, but instead of playing songs like Cherub Rock for the 4000th time, they had a whole new regiment of songs? What would they sound like? Would it be D'arcy or Melissa? Discuss.

Originally posted by ckeegan
...the Pumpkins got back together, but instead of playing songs like Cherub Rock for the 4000th time, they had a whole new regiment of songs? What would they sound like? Would it be D'arcy or Melissa? Discuss.

That would be cool, actually. But D'arcy will never return. Not even for the reunion tour.

i'd dig it, but i would want at least a few of the oldies. but coming back with a ton of songs for a new album would be great.

i'd fear it would be much like Zwan.

Originally posted by peabody
i'd fear it would be much like Zwan.

I do too. But it would be kind of cool

nah, it'll be after Zwan falls on its face and Billy will get all depressed again because no one understands him and his art so we'd get another dark and gloomy more industrial sounding Pumpkins album

no, that wouldn't be cool.

Go D'arcy! :rockon:

pfrt all u people say u wouldn't like it, but probably travel so many miles to see them so..
I would definitly be all pro, and cross countrys(holland france germany) to see them

Originally posted by smashingjj
no, that wouldn't be cool.

I can't see it happening, but if it did...i would want older songs still l*******d. I mean, who wouldn't want to hear Cherub Rock if they saw the pumpkins in the future?