<b>Does anyone <i>like</i> this song?</b>

Seriously, it's a horrible setlist killer. It is also chock full of those damn 'b0lly missing initial-consonant words'

oouu an eear lass alllinnnnn

Ugh.

lol, I like it

i hate it live.. it is a set killer. and it just pisses me off, it makes me think of the machina mystery and anyone who was around during that era most likely has the same feeling

admittedly i liked the last minute or so ... but seriously if i wanted shitty phish-sounding tripMusic i'd be going to more drug parties.

i like the song a lot but i havent heard the live version. is there a utube?

admittedly i liked the last minute or so ... but seriously if i wanted shitty phish-sounding tripMusic i'd be going to more drug parties.
:smoke:

i like the song a lot but i havent heard the live version. is there a utube?

streamable here: http://www.archive.org/details/tsp2007-09-28.raw.aud.flac24

playing this at festivals is the height of idiocy

:smoke:
<object width="450" height="540"><param name="movie" value="http://backend.deviantart.com/embed/view.swf"></param><param name="flashvars" value="id=44942962" /><embed src="http://backend.deviantart.com/embed/view.swf" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" width="450" flashvars="id=44942962" height="540"></embed></object><br /><a href="http://www.deviantart.com/deviation/44942962/">Glass and the ghost children</a> by ~<a class="u" href="http://hellmonkey42.deviantart.com/">hellmonkey42</a> on <a href="http://www.deviantart.com">deviant</a><a href="http://www.deviantart.com">ART</a>

playing this at festivals is the height of idiocy
I agree with this comment.

playing it on your tour is the height of idiocy. most of these people didn't know about machina.

i like the song
but it's over-done

streamable here: http://www.archive.org/details/tsp2007-09-28.raw.aud.flac24


Thanks Wasabi! How do I download that entire show to my computer?

you click on all the little links at the bottom and save em

its so beautiful

its so beautiful
somehow i thought you were a little less n00b than this.

Call me crazy... I love this song, and it's even better now. I like that billy's playing machina songs. It shows that sp is picking up where it left off, more or less and moving forward-- not just playing the hits like Aerosmith or something.

superchrist is amazing. i love it

im not that great with the downloading stuff yet. soon enough though. it seems like with that concert though some of the songs stop before they are finished. is that because the taper's recording thing didnt get it or is that because my computer wont load it. like how utube stops and starts (which totally aggra's me. it is one of the most top annoying things on the planet to me beside my bf's radar system. i cant STAND radar systems, and i dont use them and when they go off they are so irritating- thanks for listening) also the songs are like one song behind when it gets to 1979. there is no name for 1979 and so its one song off after that. its nice to hear the show though. most definately

superchrist is amazing. i love it
make a new thread?

mayday is a troll guys

Much to my surprise, GATGC was one of the highlights of the Normal show for me. I get why a lot of people hate it, but I seriously just think it's crazy-good. There's so much atmosphere, and the last minute is so intense.

Plus, Lisa is wonderful, and she gets an opportunity to show off :)

lisa rockin the hammond ftw

im not that great with the downloading stuff yet. soon enough though. it seems like with that concert though some of the songs stop before they are finished. is that because the taper's recording thing didnt get it or is that because my computer wont load it. like how utube stops and starts (which totally aggra's me. it is one of the most top annoying things on the planet to me beside my bf's radar system. i cant STAND radar systems, and i dont use them and when they go off they are so irritating- thanks for listening) also the songs are like one song behind when it gets to 1979. there is no name for 1979 and so its one song off after that. its nice to hear the show though. most definately

nice try fuckwit

<b>Does anyone <i>like</i> this song?</b>




No, you are right, no one likes the song.

playing this at festivals is the height of idiocy


Now that I agree with.

Lisa is wonderful..... :)

you and i agree on something!?! amazing!

but still as wonderful as lisa is, i would prefer her to spend her time on more worth wild things.

on 9 19 it was one of my highlights. It is the audiences time to calm down talk and all that jazz but i thought it was fuck'n great. Are their any songs you fuck'ng people do like?

I don't mind the song as much as what it does to the crowd. It's a total buzz-kill. If I were judging it on the basis of how good the performance is, I would give it an A. The new arrangement is a big improvement and there's a lot of musicianship involved. Unfortunately, it tends to get pretty boring and 99% of the people in the crowd hate it, myself *******d.

I think Ruby, Porcelina, or Soma would go over much better if he has to play 15 minute songs.

<object width="450" height="540"><param name="movie" value="http://backend.deviantart.com/embed/view.swf"></param><param name="flashvars" value="id=44942962" /><embed src="http://backend.deviantart.com/embed/view.swf" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" width="450" flashvars="id=44942962" height="540"></embed></object><br /><a href="http://www.deviantart.com/deviation/44942962/">Glass and the ghost children</a> by ~<a class="u" href="http://hellmonkey42.deviantart.com/">hellmonkey42</a> on <a href="http://www.deviantart.com">deviant</a><a href="http://www.deviantart.com">ART</a>

I like that too :D

Much to my surprise, GATGC was one of the highlights of the Normal show for me...
on 9 19 it was one of my highlights...
It was a highlight for me at Red Rocks!! ;)
Highlights for me in.cluded: ... Glass and the Ghost Children (some awesome Lisa solos)

This song along with Heavy Metal Machine are the only gripes I have of this tour, as far as the setlists are concerned. Both are the same to me in that I didn't like the original MACHINA versions of 'em, and I don't care for these "new & improved" versions of 'em currently being played on tour. It's especially frustrating when considering how lengthy these two songs are.

i really like the new HMM, i liked the old one too...
both of the glasses are less than thrilling for me, but at the very least hmm keeps some measure of crowd interest.

I actually quite like this new version, though I agree that it kills the festival sets.

The new version is quite tasty. The little organ solo is awesome!

I think it is alright. Most of the people at Normal got a little too relaxed during it, but I thought it was pretty cool. Definitely more about atmosphere than sheer entertainment, though.

I like it, but they should leave it off most setlists, ESPECIALLY festivals. Replace it with Rhinoceros or Porcelina or something. I'd love to see what Lisa could do with Porcelina.

I think Ruby, Porcelina, or Soma would go over much better if he has to play 15 minute songs.
^

I like it, but they should leave it off most setlists, ESPECIALLY festivals. Replace it with Rhinoceros or Porcelina or something. I'd love to see what Lisa could do with Porcelina.

yeah, i like the new G+tGC all right, but there are much better songs they could be playing during that precious 2 hours. like Ruby or Rhino or Porcelina, etc

:noway:

got a little too relaxed during it

heh. for some reason i like the word choice here.

Davin was passin' `round a fatty. Everyone was too baked.

Keeping on topic, I didn't mind the GATGC, but I think 1100ww was right... that the crowd would probably respond better to Ruby or Rhino or Porcelina.

HMM was good too, new incarnation and all, but I've always been a fan of the album version and wouldn't have minded that either.

Personally, I like the current version, but understand how some netphorians don't like it. I wouldn't mind hearing GATGC acoustically.

VH1 Storytellers, anyone?

i should find the dvd for that. somewhere.

i should find the dvd for that. somewhere.
I have never seen that whole thing. Is there someplace to download it?

For the record: if I saw them play Porcelina live I would almost assuredly cream my jeans.

haven't experienced it in the flesh, but it's been a major highlight of the recordings for me. thumbs up! GATGC! fuck yeah!

Love it, can't get enough of it.

i'm sorry to say that i have seen them do it live at least 5 times now (old and new pumpkins) and it sucks. it sucks it sucks it sucks. it even alienated an audience of nothing but hardcore pumpkins fans at the fillmore. let it die please. if he still has this ridiculous need to play machina stuff then he should play the age of innocence or something. NOT heavy metal machine (which incidentally was incredible and mindblowing at the fillmore, it was like it kept getting heavier and heavier and heavier and never stopped, but now on the tour completely sucks) , and certainly not glass and the ghost children. thanks for listening. or not.

-jeff

I like it. Especially the end.

I hated it on the disc and live it's a dud. The original version of HMM is so much better, especially that chorus. The new live version is boring.

but still as wonderful as lisa is, i would prefer her to spend her time on more worth wild things.

I'd rather "not know how to use the quote button" than say "worth wild."

Dummy.

;) :love:

I'd rather "not know how to use the quote button" than say "worth wild."

Dummy.



use the quote button twit

Stop fighting!! :cry:

Stop fighting!! :cry:

Ya! START QUOTING RIGHT!

For the record: if I saw them play Porcelina live I would almost assuredly cream my jeans.

Seconded.

lol... breathe, monte.

Have you been hanging out with Corgan Rules?

And for the record, I'm well aware of how to use the quote button, but people like you just make me want to not use it.

you're so edgy

I like the last 2 minutes. prior to that. not so much. why not have the arising tour version plus that rocked out ending? how amazing would that be?

you're so edgy

just annoying.

GATGC is bewilderingly beautiful. It's breathtaking

I finally listened to the 10/7 show. Talk about painful (GATGC I mean). Seriously, I like most SP alternate versions, I think HMM is rockin this tour, but this version is complete crap. Ugh

It was okay in Asheville. No wonder you guys said it killed the show. I thought you were exaggerating! ha

the beginning and middle of this new jam are awesome. i could give a fuck what "average fans" think of this in terms of the flow of the set. its godo spacey fun. :smoke:

when the solo kicks in it gives me chills. but it takes forever to get there. worth it? probably not.

liked both of the originals, liked both of the original versions live, and like both of the new live versions

the beginning and middle of this new jam are awesome. i could give a fuck what "average fans" think of this in terms of the flow of the set. its godo spacey fun. :smoke:

To each their own. I personally find it really bad. And I think the new band rocks live, almost everything I say/think about them is positive.

I'm sure it was cool in person.

i'm actually surprised they haven't played age of innocence