View Full Version : ST 10396473: Pumpkins, Best to Worst


mpp
07-25-2002, 05:23 PM
what's it been? 2 weeks? here goes:


1. Adore
2. Gish
3. Siamese Dream
4. Pisces Iscariot
(big drop)
5. MACHINA II
6. Mellon Collie
7. MACHINA I

i've been a huge SP fan since 1993 (seen them 13 times including the final show), and my opinions have changed so much over time; now that they're over, i have to say this'll be my final list...siamese dream and pisces iscariot might over take gish...maybe

Ugly
07-25-2002, 05:34 PM
1. Siamese Dream
2. Adore
3. Mellon Collie
4. MACHINA
5. Gish

------------------
I'm not gay.
I'm not gay.
But I dance around in a gay, gay way.

karmacoma
07-25-2002, 05:49 PM
1. siamese dream
2. mellon collie
3. adore
4. gish
5. pisces iscariot
6. machina
7. machina ii

[This message has been edited by karmacoma (edited 07-25-2002).]

Graveflower
07-25-2002, 05:53 PM
1. Siamese Dream
2. Adore
3. Mellon Collie
4. Gish
5. Pisces Iscariot
6. Machina II
7. Machina

JoaoMiguel
07-25-2002, 06:19 PM
1. Siamese Dream (will always be number 1)
2. Mellon Collie
3. Gish
4. Pisces Iscariot
5. Adore
6. Machina II
7. Machina
.
.
.
263. Zwan (kidding http://www.netphoria.org/wwwboard/biggrin.gif)

Jaggie
07-25-2002, 06:23 PM
1. Siamese Dream
2. Pisces Iscariot
3. MCIS
4. Machina 2
5. Gish
6. Adore
7. Machina

------------------
i wasted (http://www.jaggie.net) all my years, been chasing all my fears

Xteenmachine
07-25-2002, 06:40 PM
1.MCIS
2.PI
3.Adore
4.SD
5.M2
6.Machina
7.Gish

I was suprised at how quickly I came up with that. SD isn't doing it for me anymore http://www.netphoria.org/wwwboard/frown.gif while MCIS continues to reveal more of its beauty..

Eulogy
07-25-2002, 06:55 PM
1. Machina
2. Adore
3. Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness
4. SD/PI
5. Gish

Salena Child
07-25-2002, 06:56 PM
1.adore
2. siamese dream
3. mellon collie
4. gish
5. pisces iscariot
6. machina
7. faeomm

Ensoul
07-25-2002, 07:02 PM
1. Machina
2. Adore
3. MCIS
4. Siamese Dream
5. PI
6. Machina II
7. Gish

I am the only one on these forums who thinks Machina kicked ass.

VegasPumpkin
07-25-2002, 07:06 PM
1.MCIS
2.Siamese Dream
3.Machina
4.Machina 2
5.pisces iscariot
6.Gish
7.Adore

relaxor!
07-25-2002, 07:18 PM
(these are all basically tied)
MCIS
PI
SD
Machina
Adore

Machina II
Gish

THRILLHO
07-25-2002, 07:21 PM
mellon collie
adore
pisces iscariot
the aeroplane flies high
siamese dream
gish
judas o
machina
machina 2

just my personal prefs. i just don't listen to SD much anymore.

[This message has been edited by THRILLHO (edited 07-25-2002).]

Tessellation
07-25-2002, 07:40 PM
1.SD

2. MCIS

3. PI

4. ADORE

5. GISH

6. MACHINA 2

7. MACHINA

er...5, 098, 876: Zwan-"cash cow"

[This message has been edited by Tessellation (edited 07-25-2002).]

neopryn
07-25-2002, 08:36 PM
1. MCIS
2. Machina II
3. Adore
4. Machina
5. Siamese Dream
6. Pisces Iscariot
7. Gish

Mayfuck
07-25-2002, 11:03 PM
1. MCIS
2 Adore
Siamese Dream
4. The Aeroplane Flies High
5. Pisces Iscariot
6. MACHINA II
7. Gish
8. MACHINA

The Happy Penis
07-26-2002, 01:50 AM
1.McIs
2.Gish
3.Sd
4.Pi
5.Adore
6.Machina
7.Machina2

Deege
07-26-2002, 02:19 AM
1. Siamese Dream
2. Mellon Collie
3. Pisces Iscariot
4. Machina 1/2
5. Gish
6. Adore

------------------
No way to disconnect

ZackZ
07-26-2002, 03:29 AM
1. Mellon Collie
2. Siamese Dream
3. Gish
4. Machina 2
5. Adore
6. Pisces Iscariot
7. Machina

1-3 are so very close together. MCIS is picked because of the vastness of the music on it. Siamese Dream was just completely new and inventive when it came out and still is really. Gish rocked, and rocked hard. Machina 2 has some of THE BEST Pumpkins songs. Adore was very solid, although doesn't have the versatility of other albums. Pisces, well it is very disjointed although it has awesome music. Machina, <sigh>, why Billy, why. We wanted rock, not drama. Concept albums are supposed to have a concept that actually makes sense. Billy should have talked to Pete Townshend before he made Machina.

Oblivious
07-26-2002, 04:16 AM
1. mcis
2. adore
3. pieces iscariot
4. siamese dream
5. machina
6. machina II
7. gish

jackboot7
07-26-2002, 08:02 AM
Siamese Dream
Gish
Adore
Mcis/Pisces
Machina

The Gaddrow
07-26-2002, 08:40 AM
1. MCIS
2. Adore
3. Machina II
4. Siamese Dream
5. Pisces
6. Machina
7. Gish

Though 5-7 change constantly and the only reason Piscies ranks # 5 is because Starla ownz me.

------------------
petrifiedreadhed (10:32:18 PM): the one man band is in Vince's pants??

melombar
07-26-2002, 09:29 AM
I can't do it. But, not that I don't appreciate it, I can do this one easily.

7. Machina II


------------------
Acoustic Wonderland is the greatest.

BlueStar
07-26-2002, 10:51 AM
<font color=#ADD8E6>1. Siamese Dream
2. Adore
3. Machina II
4. Machina I
5. MCIS
6. Pisces Iscariot
7. Judas O (if you ******* PI, I think you need to ******* this one)
8. Gish

And that list pretty much changes all the time (though the top 3 are generally always in the top 3).

------------------
~*~Samantha~*~

http://homepages.nyu.edu/~sag249/sigankle.jpg

Nidhogg
07-26-2002, 12:09 PM
1. Adore
2. Mellon Collie and the Infinte Sadness
3. MACHINA/the machines of God
4. Siamese Dream
5. Gish
6. Judas 0
7. Pisces Iscariot
8. MACHINA II/friends and enemies of modern music
9. The Aeroplane Flies High

Siamese Dream used to be #2. I just got tired of it, plain and simple. It seems to me that for some reason I'm always finding new songs that I like on Mellon Collie. Adore is very personal to me and has some of my favorite songs on it (Ava Adore, Blank Page, To Sheila) so it is #1 forever. I can't figure out why I love Machina 1 so much, I just do. Gish rocks. Judas 0 is underrated as are so many of the songs on it (Because You Are, Sparrow, Lucky 13, Soot and Stars). 7-9 are albums that I really like, but just don't love. There really isn't a Pumpkin's album I don't like. I consider myself lucky.

------------------
Marrow
Marrow
Silent Sparrow

Example
07-26-2002, 12:23 PM
1.Siamese Dream
2.Adore
3.Gish
4.Mellon Collie
5.Machina
6.PI
7.Judas O

As far As I'm concerned you can either count Judas 0 or Machina as an album, but not both. Same for Judas 0 and TAFH.

lily1only
07-26-2002, 02:32 PM
Mellon Collie
Siamese Dream
TAFH
Adore
PI
Gish
Machina II
Machina I

Green Plastic
07-26-2002, 04:12 PM
Siamese Dream
Mellon Collie
Adore
PI
TAFH
Machina II
Gish
Machina
Judas O

------------------
Did somebody call a doctor?
http://www.my-mistake.net/infinitepics/billy/billy545.jpg

andysong
07-26-2002, 11:22 PM
1. siamese dream
2. mcis
3. adore
4. gish
5. machina
6. pisces iscariot

Undone
07-26-2002, 11:41 PM
<font color="CC33CC">1. mellon collie
2. sd and adore
3. pisces and tafh
4. both machinas and gish

I really, really wanted to like Machina, I just can't. It could have been one of the greats with all of the strong Machina era songs like Home, Go, SIYL, This Time, Speed Kills etc. (or in LMGTWTY's case, non-era songs), sharp production on said songs, no story or 'you have to interpret it ___ way' shit. Blargh I'll just make my own mix while wishing some of the songs included on it didn't sound like I was listening to it in a rainstorm.

gleemonexforpets
07-27-2002, 06:34 AM
1. Siamese Dream

everything else:
2. Machina
3. Adore
4. Machina 2
5. PI
6. Gish
7. MCIS

Nate the Grate
07-27-2002, 12:00 PM
1. MCIS
2. Siamese Dream
3. Adore
4. TAFH
5. Machina II
6. Pisces Iscariot
7. Gish
8. Machina
9. Judas O

that was easy

Cactuar
07-28-2002, 07:11 AM
Adore
MCIS
TAFH
PI
SD
Gish
Machina
Machina 2

Brazil.Virex
07-28-2002, 08:56 AM
sd
mcis
adore
gish
TAFH
PI
machina 2
machina
judas

eyesbomb
07-28-2002, 11:09 AM
1. Mellon Collie & the Infinite Sadness
2. Machina i & ii
3. Siamese Dream
4. Pisces Iscariot
5. Adore
6. Gish
7. Judas O

Nothing/everything
07-28-2002, 11:13 AM
1. Gish
2. MCIS
3. PI
4. Adore
5. SD
6. M2
7. MI
8. Judas O

------------------
http://www.bioledu.rug.nl/s1210262/evil.jpg
Bootlist (http://www.bioledu.rug.nl/s1210262/bootlist/)