It kind of sucks when the pumpkins myspace continues to post songs sung by Iha a week after he announced he's not in the band.

If you really think about it, it'd be worse if they didn't play his songs.

which sucks worse? that he's not in the band or that we have to listen to his music?

i think it's the latter.

His voice sucks, but I wish they'd at least stop pretending that nothing's changed.

so thats not a pumpkins song anymore??

yeah, but billy did everything on it.. along with all of james's songs. because face it: billy IS the smashing pumpkins. he even sang the songs d'arcy sang

....um i was kidding...

it would be cool if the new pumpkins played blew away or the boy a james sp song on this tour

I highly doubt Billy has anything to do with what songs are played on myspace. Lets get real people.

so thats not a pumpkins song anymore??

My thoughts exactly. You know, James was there for the best part of the Pumpkins. Just because he's not in the new lineup doesn't mean you can erase everything ever written or sung by him. And he can write a better song than you, STR.

Tardass.

I highly doubt Billy has anything to do with what songs are played on myspace. Lets get real people.
<img src="http://forums.netphoria.org/wwwboard/icons/icon14.gif">

posting that song on myspace only reminds me of how retarded it is that he no longer a part of the "Smashing Pumpkins."

what a god damn stinking joke. "We've become our own cover band." -BC

I highly doubt Billy has anything to do with what songs are played on myspace. Lets get real people.

:lock:

yeah, but billy did everything on it.. along with all of james's songs. because face it: billy IS the smashing pumpkins. he even sang the songs d'arcy sang

Billy wishes he did everything on it. I only have one word to say to the James nearsayers 'falling'.

No matter how much Billy wishes it he never was the smashing pumpkins and never will be.

I think Billy needs to go to Lacuna Inc. and get the procedure done.


"the more you change the less you feel"

My thoughts exactly. You know, James was there for the best part of the Pumpkins. Just because he's not in the new lineup doesn't mean you can erase everything ever written or sung by him. And he can write a better song than you, STR.

Tardass.

You're missing the point. I'm not saying to erase everything ever written by the pumpkins. James was a pumpkin, and that is clearly a pumpkins song. Not an Iha song. And I know Billy doesn't have anything to do with the sites.

I really liked the whole nostalgic feel of the site, posting old songs and demos, but at this point, I'm ready for some reality. It's just completely ignoring a very dynamic change in the pumpkins to continue posting that stuff. It's like making Clinton a foreign ambassador. Ok, yeah, he was a president, and you still call him Mr. President. But, I mean, what the fuck. What the fuck.

Ok, bad analogy.

what a god damn stinking joke. "We've become our own cover band." -BC

when-tf did he actually say that?

I think he said it in a live recording somewhere in some year. Really.

same as boring as "GO"

for me, "one and two" tops it all off.

sup, '|'jIMMY'|'?

wave song is good

same as boring as "GO"

for me, "one and two" tops it all off.

go was one of the best songs on machina 2 and probably james' best song.