which would you rather the new album's sound resemble? siamese dream or gish?


I personally favor a gish sound.

i also prefer the GISH sound.

however, knowing that SP will never rehash something they have already done.......i think it would be awesome to start with that GISH sound as a base, and then evolve it into a different direction than SD, but still one that is rooted in GISH. Does that make sense? Like going back to step 1, but ending up with a different step 2. :smoke:

Machina.

i also prefer the GISH sound.

however, knowing that SP will never rehash something they have already done.......i think it would be awesome to start with that GISH sound as a base, and then evolve it into a different direction than SD, but still one that is rooted in GISH. Does that make sense? Like going back to step 1, but ending up with a different step 2. :smoke:

yea, use the gish sound as foundation.... and then just see what develops.
any album that evolves from gish will be absolutely awful!!! I can't wait!

Gish was more about dynamics; SD was more about blowing your head off

its all about preference i guess

Gish was more about dynamics; SD was more about blowing your head off

its all about preference i guess

Gish was more about dynamics; SD was more about blowing your head off

its all about preference i guess

yeah, gish was totally about the crescendos and decrescendos. i love it, it's all very climactic.

GISH by far

A combo between the epicness of Gish and the songwriting finesse of SD would be wonderful. It'll never happen though.

you fucking retards
do you think billy and jimmy are gonna be sitting in a room, pondering the precentage of each of their old album's sound they would like to add up to their upcoming record?
"hmm i think we should set teh brain knob to gish and then try and evolve from there"

"oh no man, i think we should take the unrefined squealing of gish and mix it with the rocking foundations of the soaring sd, and sprinkle some mcis dust all over that"

you either give them too much credit or thinking way too much into it.
they're just gonna get a in a fucking room and play and see what comes out.
geebus

"hmm i think we should set teh brain knob to gish and then try and evolve from there"



:rofl:

petition to delete the sp board

I disagree with Gish being a more dymanic album than Siamese Dream. Today, Hummer, Soma, Geek USA, Mayonaise, Spaceboy, Silverfuck... they all have amazing dynamic expressions. From loud, to angelically quiet, to screaming, to soothing... all in seconds of a transition.

SD - absolutely!!! One of the best Rock-albums of the 90s! Still very powerful sound and great guitar-production!

SIAMESE DREAM CAUSE I NEVER LISTEN to gish. i ran out of enthusiasm.

Gish

i also prefer the GISH sound.




lol. you're one of a kind <thankfully>

*GISH*

Always reminds me of the sound of Jimmy's cymbols.

i'd prefer the fish sound.

i really do enjoy soma on sd though...
but i think gish has a more solid sound. if that makes any sense

i want them to sound like the smashing pumpkins

and what is that sound bonnie

I love the sound of the drums on Gish. It's very solid and in your face... Song-wise, I prefer SD's content.


they're just gonna get a in a fucking room and play and see what comes out.
geebus


yup, I agree

the new album is going to be called siamese pishes. it will contain all the good things from gish, sd and pi. omg i can't wait.

and what is that sound bonnie
miraculous

you fucking retards
do you think billy and jimmy are gonna be sitting in a room, pondering the precentage of each of their old album's sound they would like to add up to their upcoming record?
"hmm i think we should set teh brain knob to gish and then try and evolve from there"

"oh no man, i think we should take the unrefined squealing of gish and mix it with the rocking foundations of the soaring sd, and sprinkle some mcis dust all over that"

you either give them too much credit or thinking way too much into it.
they're just gonna get a in a fucking room and play and see what comes out.
geebus
Well, they can't predict the results to an infinite degree, but Billy usually seems to have a pretty good idea of what kind of sound he wants before he makes an album.

nevermind

I would hope it doesnt sound like SD and has more of a live band feel like Gish. Gish has all four members contributing unlike SD.

Set the ray to Gish

while giving me head the other day, corgan told me its really just a return to the cyber metal. and he's ready to rock again. i think. i don't know it was kinda muffled.

don't be jealous davin

SD, Gish is my least liked album from them.

Gish, definitely.

SD, Gish is my least liked album from them.
Why!?

yeah, why?!

i like gish, but i find that sd is much more varied.
many of gish's songs sound VERY similar.
a return to either of the sounds would be well accepted from me though.

SD easily.

Why? I don't know I guess just personal preference. I did not get into The Smashing Pumpkins until last year when I found a copy of SD in my dads basement, and got instantly hooked. Didn't get around to getting gish until after I had already bought and listened the fuck out of MCIS, Adore, & PI. So I guess by the time I got to Gish it just felt too raw to what I had gotten used to.

yeah, gish was totally about the crescendos and decrescendos. i love it, it's all very climactic.
you totally missed a chance to say descendo(s)

Why? I don't know I guess just personal preference. I did not get into The Smashing Pumpkins until last year when I found a copy of SD in my dads basement, and got instantly hooked. Didn't get around to getting gish until after I had already bought and listened the fuck out of MCIS, Adore, & PI. So I guess by the time I got to Gish it just felt too raw to what I had gotten used to.
same hither.
except i didnt find sd in my dad's basement.
i got mcis for christmas and bought the rest.