Will Bill play those songs live if James isn't with the band? No more I Am One? Farewell and Goodnight?

...mayonaise

Well, there are others. I just didn't want to mention them all. Still, my question stands.

i do not know.

he's already said they will be performing The Bells regularly, so i don't see why they wouldn't play songs he co-wrote.

hahah jame's didn't really co-write i am one. billy just felt bad for him so he added james name to the credits.

i think james wrote that descending scale thing.

He's gonna send James some sweet sweet cash every time they play one

"here james, since you wrote 2% of I am one. you will receive .01 cents ever time we play it live."

i bet james only wrote the intro/outro to mayonaise that we hear on siamese dream.

Soma too!

James rules

i bet james only wrote the intro/outro to mayonaise that we hear on siamese dream.

the song wouldn't exist without him. billy wrote the song around the chords that james came up with

They sucked.

he's already said they will be performing The Bells regularly, so i don't see why they wouldn't play songs he co-wrote.
Thanks for the warning :earplugs:

Will Bill play those songs live if James isn't with the band? No more I Am One? Farewell and Goodnight?


doubtful

james and i hug eachother from time to time

Billy can do whatever the hell he wants

Billy can do whatever the hell he wants
Fanboy

Fanboy
hardly. my distaste for corgan grows deeper everyday

hardly. my distaste for corgan grows deeper everyday
So how many days passed from your previous post in this thread?

I think if Billy has the will to reform the Pumpkins without James, he'll also have no problem playing songs he wrote with him. Think about it.

Thanks for the warning :earplugs:

Dude , that song (the Bells) rocks (OK, maybe not, but it is darn good). I like Summer too, and Said Sadly and Believe. Maybe James only contributed 5% to the Pumpkins' songwriting chores, but it was a good 5%.

ya, I totally agree. I mean, Blew Away????

Ha. Oh, the Boy is cool also.

james only contributed on good song, mayonaisse, every other one i HOPE billy doesn't play

Corgan is over-rated.

I SAY FUCK JAMES, IF THAT INSINCERE AND UNFAITHFUL FUCKER CAN'T GET OFF HIS LAZY ASS TO JOIN THE GREATEST BAND OF ALL TIME. FUCK JAMES IHA.

I SAY FUCK JAMES, IF THAT INSINCERE AND UNFAITHFUL FUCKER CAN'T GET OFF HIS LAZY ASS TO JOIN THE GREATEST BAND OF ALL TIME. FUCK JAMES IHA.
The greatest band of all time.... EVAR!

SHUT THE FUCK UP.

james only contributed on good song, mayonaisse, every other one i HOPE billy doesn't play


you don't like soma? Stop trying to fit in.

I SAY FUCK JAMES, IF THAT INSINCERE AND UNFAITHFUL FUCKER CAN'T GET OFF HIS LAZY ASS TO JOIN THE GREATEST BAND OF ALL TIME. FUCK JAMES IHA.
YEA FUCK JAMES THEN!! WOO!!

i think james wrote that descending scale thing.

rofl you mean he took a scale that already existed and just played it in the song, without making not sound like a scale

soma is really the most important of all these songs.

your sister's ass.
it's a metaphor. but that actually happened though.
http://www.cinemazone.dk/images/image8687.JPG

mayonaisse

Good job, Warren.

I think James will be around for the new reformed Pumpkins, and this will all be a moot point. And also considering that I doubt they will be playing hardly any old songs anyway makes it double moot.

Either way, if James is around or not, the only thing he really provided to the band was a couple extra points in the image diversity department. Most of his songs pretty much sucked, or maybe it was just that his voice was undesirable and made the songs he sang on sound worse.

I thought you were claiming a while back that he would be in the new lineup - very hush-hush about the source but I believe you pm'ed the info to Davin?

I think James will be around for the new reformed Pumpkins, and this will all be a moot point. And also considering that I doubt they will be playing hardly any old songs anyway makes it double moot.

Either way, if James is around or not, the only thing he really provided to the band was a couple extra points in the image diversity department. Most of his songs pretty much sucked, or maybe it was just that his voice was undesirable and made the songs he sang on sound worse.

How do you figure they won't play much of the back catalogue?

I agree with you that James' voice wasn't up to much, but I think his Pumpkins songs were pretty OK actually.

I thought you were claiming a while back that he would be in the new lineup - very hush-hush about the source but I believe you pm'ed the info to Davin?

Yeah, that's what I just said. Thanks for repeating it.

dude, if you pm'd it to anyone, it kind of implies that you actually know it

Dude , that song (the Bells) rocks (OK, maybe not, but it is darn good). I like Summer too, and Said Sadly and Believe. Maybe James only contributed 5% to the Pumpkins' songwriting chores, but it was a good 5%.


UI srtongly agree with this.

UI srtongly agree with this.

okay, i'm a retard who can't type properly. I strongly agree, I meant.

I like a lot of James' songs, but I guess I just don't like his voice as well as Billy's. As for whether the Pumpkins will play them, my bet is that they play the cowritten songs, but not any that James wrote on his own. Hopefully James will be there anyway and none of this will be a problem.

The Boy is cool also.

Just hoping they can be mature about this and bury the hatchet (or whatever).

James is a fag

James is a fag
did you pm this to anyone?

And also considering that I doubt they will be playing hardly any old songs anyway makes it double moot.

"I want my songs back"? :think:

James is a faq

Ain't it the truth.

"I can't stop, I can't breathe, I can't think
I'm in love again
I don't need, I don't eat, I don't sleep
I'm in love again
I can't stop, I can't breathe, I can't think
I'm in love again
I don't need, I don't eat, I don't sleep
I'm in love again
The boy, the boy's in love
The boy, the boy's in love
The boy, the boy's in love
The boy, the boy's in love"
^
nothing gay about that

Unless he's talking about his cat :erm:

you dont know what happened. billy could have been a complete dickhead to him, which is very likely.
james is oh so very hot!